Indian Gaming Today

Tuesday, January 30, 2007

Indian Gaming as “Public Gaming”

Thread: The Big Picture

At times we like to return to "the big picture" of Indian gaming. We've mentioned in other posts that sometimes people seem to conflate tribal gaming with commercial gaming. So what is so different about Indian gaming? It depends on your perspective, of course, but among the reasons are:

Public vs. private sector. Indian gaming is “public gaming” – that is, government-sponsored and government-operated. Indian gaming, therefore, is more akin to a state lottery than to a Vegas casino. The profit motive and revenue use are quite different.

Legal frameworks and policy rationale. The legal framework for Indian gaming sets forth Congress’s specific federal policy goals, which include generating reservation economic development, promoting strong tribal governments, and tribal self-sufficiency. The underlying public policy goals are very different than those for commercial or charitable gaming.

State regulatory role. States have less of a say-so in how Indian gaming is regulated than they do for other forms of gaming. This doesn’t mean that Indian gaming is unregulated; instead, its regulatory structure is unique, as casino-style gaming on reservations involves federal, state, and tribal regulation.

Constitutional rationale. Aha – this is the big one, since last time we checked, there was no mention of gambling in the U.S. Constitution. Yet there is a constitutional rationale for Indian gaming: tribal sovereignty. It's tribal sovereignty, arguably, that presents the most difficult questions for constitutional or Indian law scholars and the "rest of us" alike.


We'll return to this "big picture" issue of tribal sovereignty, so be sure to look out for our thoughts on that.

3 Comments:

  • Good aftenoon !
    xanax http://xanax1akk.blogspot.com
    phentermine http://phentermine-akm.blogspot.com
    cialis http://cialis-akss.blogspot.com
    tramadol http://tramadol3akss.blogspot.com
    tramadol http://tramadol3akak3.blogspot.com
    viagra http://viagra-0ak0.blogspot.com
    Good stuff, very nicely done.
    viagra http://viagra-akkk.blogspot.com
    xanax http://xanax-akx5.blogspot.com
    phentermine http://phentermine45akl7.blogspot.com
    cialis http://cialis-3ak7d.blogspot.com
    Well, thanks!

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at Monday, February 05, 2007 3:25:00 AM  

  • Ya right! Individual indians get free housing (equal to 800k homes in San Diego) in addition to becoming rich individually. The state gets a relative pittance (population of California, about 36 million, money to the state from indian gambling, about 500 million = less than 14 per person) What a joke. The state should get more than that just to pay for gambling treatment programs. The individual indians also recieve all the benefits of living in the state without paying for them (no state taxes, no property taxes)

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at Sunday, March 11, 2007 4:54:00 PM  

  • Online Viagra resource containing quality information on Erectile Dysfunction, Impotence, Viagra News, Viagra Usage, Viagra Forum etc to help you understand the most effective treatment available for Erectile Dysfunction(Impotence)http://www.viagracare.com

    By Blogger John, at Wednesday, September 24, 2008 11:31:00 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home